Allegations of Research Misconduct

Ar Rehla: Journal of Islamic Tourism, Halal Food, Islamic Traveling, and Creative Economy is committed to addressing allegations of research and publication misconduct fairly, objectively, confidentially, and responsibly. This policy applies to suspected violations involving submitted manuscripts, published articles, and individuals participating in the editorial and publication process.

Allegations may involve data fabrication or falsification, plagiarism, authorship misconduct, citation or peer-review manipulation, unethical research practices, or other violations affecting research integrity. Allegations must be evaluated based on relevant evidence rather than treated as confirmed misconduct.

1. Reporting Allegations

Authors, reviewers, editors, readers, research institutions, and other concerned parties may report suspected research or publication misconduct to the editorial office.

Reports should include:

  1. The title of the manuscript or published article, including its submission number, DOI, or URL where available.

  2. A clear description of the suspected misconduct.

  3. Relevant evidence or supporting documentation.

  4. The reporter's contact information, where provided.

Anonymous reports may be considered when sufficient credible evidence is available for assessment.

Reports can be submitted through the Journal Contact page.

2. Preliminary Assessment

Upon receiving an allegation, the Editor-in-Chief or a designated independent editor conducts an initial assessment to determine its relevance, credibility, and supporting evidence.

The editorial team may request additional information or clarification when necessary. Allegations lacking sufficient evidence may be closed, but reconsideration remains possible if new credible information becomes available.

3. Investigation and Clarification

When an allegation requires further examination, the editorial team may review relevant manuscripts, research records, data, editorial correspondence, and other supporting documentation.

The individuals concerned will be given a reasonable opportunity to respond and provide explanations or evidence.

For complex or serious allegations, the journal may consult independent experts or refer the matter to the relevant research institution or competent authority for further investigation.

The journal remains responsible for editorial decisions concerning its publications, while formal investigations into individual research misconduct may fall within institutional authority.

4. Confidentiality, Fairness, and Independence

All allegations must be handled impartially and with appropriate confidentiality. Information will be shared only with individuals or institutions directly involved in the assessment or investigation.

Individuals with conflicts of interest must not participate in evaluating or deciding the case. Allegations involving editorial personnel must be examined by an independent editor or appropriate institutional authority.

The journal will protect individuals reporting concerns in good faith from retaliation within its editorial processes and ensure that affected parties receive fair treatment.

5. Editorial Decisions and Follow-Up

Following the assessment, the editorial team determines appropriate action based on the available evidence, seriousness of the concern, and publication status.

Possible actions include:

  1. No Further Action: Closing allegations that are unsupported or adequately resolved.

  2. Clarification or Revision: Requesting explanations or necessary manuscript corrections.

  3. Suspension or Rejection: Suspending editorial processing or rejecting manuscripts when serious concerns remain unresolved or substantial violations are established.

  4. Post-Publication Action: Issuing a correction, expression of concern, or retraction when justified by the findings.

  5. Institutional Referral: Referring serious misconduct concerns to relevant institutions or competent authorities.

The editorial team will document the assessment, supporting evidence, decisions, and follow-up actions. Relevant parties may be informed of the outcome, subject to confidentiality requirements.

All actions must remain proportionate to the findings and consistent with the journal's Publication Ethics.