Correction and Retraction Policy

Ar Rehla: Journal of Islamic Tourism, Halal Food, Islamic Traveling, and Creative Economy is committed to maintaining the accuracy, reliability, and integrity of published scholarly works. The journal provides procedures for correcting errors, issuing expressions of concern, and retracting publications when necessary. All corrective actions are based on the available evidence and aim to preserve a transparent and trustworthy scholarly record.

1. Corrections to Published Articles

A Correction is issued when an error or omission is identified in a published article but its principal findings and conclusions remain reliable.

Corrections may address:

  1. Errors in research data, calculations, tables, figures, or statistical reporting.

  2. Inaccuracies in research methods, explanations, or interpretations.

  3. Errors in author names, affiliations, contributions, or publication information.

  4. Significant inaccuracies in citations, references, or relevant declarations.

  5. Other errors requiring clarification without invalidating the article's main findings.

Minor typographical or formatting errors that do not affect the meaning or interpretation of an article may not require a formal correction notice.

Substantive corrections must be documented through an official notice identifying the original article, explaining the error, and presenting the corrected information.

2. Retraction of Published Articles

A Retraction is issued when serious errors or research integrity concerns make a published article or its principal findings unreliable.

Retraction may be warranted in cases involving:

  1. Fabricated, falsified, or substantially unreliable research data.

  2. Fundamental methodological or analytical errors that invalidate the main findings.

  3. Serious plagiarism or inappropriate duplicate publication.

  4. Substantial research ethics violations or manipulation of the publication process.

  5. Other serious problems that cannot be adequately resolved through correction.

Retraction may result from intentional misconduct or unintentional errors. Its purpose is to correct the scholarly record rather than punish authors.

Retraction decisions must be supported by sufficient evidence. The editorial team may proceed with a justified retraction even when the authors disagree with the decision.

Retracted articles will ordinarily remain accessible in the journal's archive, clearly identified as RETRACTED and linked to the official retraction notice.

3. Expressions of Concern

An Expression of Concern may be issued when significant questions arise about the reliability or integrity of a published article, but the available evidence is insufficient to determine whether correction or retraction is necessary.

This notice informs readers that substantive concerns remain unresolved or are undergoing further assessment.

The notice must identify the affected article, explain the nature of the concerns, and avoid presenting unverified allegations as established facts.

When further evidence becomes available, the editorial team will reassess the case and may issue a correction, publish a retraction, update the notice, or formally resolve the concern.

4. Reporting and Editorial Assessment

Authors, reviewers, readers, and other concerned parties may report significant errors or concerns affecting published articles through the Journal Contact page.

Reports should identify the article title, DOI or URL, the specific problem, and relevant supporting evidence.

The editorial team will examine the reported concerns, seek clarification from the authors when appropriate, and consult independent experts or relevant institutions when necessary.

The Editor-in-Chief or an appropriately independent editor determines the corrective action based on the nature and seriousness of the findings.

Suspected research misconduct requiring further investigation will be addressed under the Allegations of Research Misconduct policy.

Authors wishing to challenge a corrective editorial decision may follow the Complaints and Appeals Policy.

5. Publication of Notices and Record Preservation

All formal corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions must be communicated transparently through official editorial notices.

Each notice must:

  1. Clearly identify the affected article, including its title and DOI or URL.

  2. State the type of editorial action and its reasons.

  3. Indicate the date of publication of the notice.

  4. Be freely accessible and linked to the original article.

  5. Provide sufficient information for readers to understand the article's current publication status.

The original article must also link to the relevant notice and display its corrected or retracted status where applicable.

Article metadata, DOI-related records, and downloadable files should be updated where technically supported to reflect the editorial action.

Corrections and retractions must not be implemented in ways that conceal significant changes to the published scholarly record.

6. Article Removal in Exceptional Circumstances

Removal of published content is considered only in exceptional circumstances involving serious legal, privacy, confidentiality, or safety concerns that cannot be adequately addressed through correction or retraction.

Where removal is necessary and legally permissible, the journal will retain essential bibliographic information and an appropriate explanatory notice to preserve the transparency of the publication record.