Post-Publication Discussion Policy

Ar Rehla: Journal of Islamic Tourism, Halal Food, Islamic Traveling, and Creative Economy encourages open, constructive, and evidence-based scholarly discussion of published articles. Authors, readers, researchers, and other interested parties may submit questions, academic comments, criticisms, or alternative interpretations to support the continuing evaluation and development of scholarly knowledge.

1. Scope of Post-Publication Discussion

Post-publication discussions may address:

  1. Theoretical and Conceptual Issues: The relevance, application, or interpretation of theories and concepts.

  2. Research Methodology: The appropriateness of research designs, data collection procedures, and analytical methods.

  3. Research Findings: The accuracy, reliability, and interpretation of research results.

  4. Scholarly Arguments: Alternative perspectives, conclusions, and implications supported by academic evidence.

  5. Research Limitations: Identified weaknesses, unanswered questions, or opportunities for further investigation.

All contributions must be relevant, academically justified, and communicated respectfully. Personal attacks, discriminatory statements, and unsupported allegations are not permitted.

2. Submission of Comments and Responses

Individuals wishing to discuss a published article may submit their comments through the journal's Official Contact Page.

Submissions should include:

  1. The title and DOI or URL of the article being discussed.

  2. A clear description of the question, criticism, or academic response.

  3. Supporting arguments, evidence, or scholarly references where appropriate.

  4. The contributor's name and contact information.

Comments should identify the specific issues requiring discussion or clarification.

3. Editorial Assessment and Author Responses

The editorial team evaluates submitted comments based on their academic relevance, clarity, supporting evidence, and potential contribution to scholarly discussion.

When appropriate, comments may be forwarded to the original authors for clarification or response. Authors are given a reasonable opportunity to address substantive questions and provide supporting explanations.

The editorial team may consult independent experts when additional academic assessment is necessary. Legitimate differences in scholarly interpretation are recognised as part of academic debate and do not automatically indicate research misconduct.

4. Publication and Follow-Up

Ar Rehla may publish selected scholarly comments, letters to the editor, academic commentaries, or author responses following appropriate editorial assessment.

Published discussions should clearly identify the original article and, where technically possible, provide links between the article, scholarly comments, and corresponding responses.

Publication of comments or responses is subject to editorial approval and is not automatic.

When a discussion identifies substantive errors or credible concerns affecting the integrity of a published article, the editorial team may initiate further assessment under the journal's applicable correction procedures or Allegations of Research Misconduct policy.

Ar Rehla is committed to facilitating responsible scholarly dialogue and ensuring that relevant post-publication discussions receive fair and appropriate editorial consideration.