Manuscript Types

Ar Rehla: Journal of Islamic Tourism, Halal Food, Islamic Traveling, and Creative Economy accepts two main types of scholarly manuscripts: Original Research Articles and Research-Based Review Articles. Both types must demonstrate academic originality, analytical depth, and a clear contribution to knowledge within the journal's Focus and Scope.

1. Original Research Article

An Original Research Article presents new findings derived from original research conducted using appropriate scientific methods. It aims to generate new knowledge, test existing theories, examine particular phenomena, or provide evidence-based explanations and solutions to research problems.

This category includes:

  • Qualitative Research: Studies using interviews, observations, case studies, ethnography, document analysis, or other qualitative approaches to investigate relevant phenomena.

  • Quantitative Research: Studies employing surveys, statistical analysis, experiments, modelling, or other quantitative techniques to examine relationships, patterns, or effects.

  • Mixed-Methods Research: Studies integrating qualitative and quantitative approaches to provide a more comprehensive understanding of research problems.

Original Research Articles must clearly establish the research problem and objectives, explain the research methodology, present findings supported by appropriate evidence, and discuss their significance in relation to existing scholarship.

The principal contribution must arise from the research findings and their theoretical, empirical, or practical implications rather than merely describing an existing situation.

2. Research-Based Review Article

A Research-Based Review Article provides a critical and systematic examination of existing scholarly literature, theories, concepts, or research findings to develop new insights into a particular subject.

Unlike an Original Research Article, this manuscript type primarily generates knowledge through the evaluation, comparison, interpretation, and synthesis of existing research rather than the collection of new empirical data.

This category includes:

  • Systematic Literature Review: A structured review employing clearly defined research questions, search strategies, selection criteria, and synthesis procedures.

  • Scoping Review: A review that maps existing research, identifies major concepts and evidence, and examines knowledge gaps within a particular field.

  • Integrative or Critical Literature Review: A review that critically evaluates and synthesises relevant studies to identify patterns, inconsistencies, theoretical developments, and opportunities for further research.

  • Conceptual or Theoretical Review: A scholarly analysis that critically examines existing concepts, theories, or frameworks to develop new interpretations, conceptual relationships, or theoretical propositions.

Research-Based Review Articles must explain the approach used to identify, select, evaluate, and analyse relevant scholarly sources. The level of methodological detail should be appropriate to the review approach employed.

Manuscripts must move beyond descriptive summaries of previous publications by providing critical synthesis, identifying research gaps, and demonstrating an original scholarly contribution. Conceptual or theoretical reviews must present coherent arguments grounded in relevant academic literature.

3. Manuscript Type Selection

Authors should select the manuscript type that best represents the primary approach and contribution of their study.

Original Research Articles are appropriate when the principal contribution comes from new research findings, while Research-Based Review Articles are appropriate when the contribution arises from critical literature synthesis or conceptual and theoretical development.

Both types may address Islamic or conventional tourism and other subjects relevant to the journal's scope, provided that the topics examined do not conflict with Islamic values and principles.

For detailed manuscript structure, formatting, citation requirements, and article preparation, authors should consult the Author Guidelines.