Complaints and Appeals Policy

Ar Rehla: Journal of Islamic Tourism, Halal Food, Islamic Traveling, and Creative Economy provides a fair, transparent, and accessible mechanism for submitting complaints and appealing editorial decisions. All complaints and appeals are handled objectively, independently, and confidentially to ensure accountability and fairness in the journal's publication process.

1. Scope of Complaints and Appeals

Complaints may be submitted by authors, reviewers, readers, researchers, or other concerned parties regarding editorial procedures, peer-review conduct, communication, administrative services, unfair treatment, or other matters affecting the journal's publication activities.

Appeals are formal requests by authors to reconsider editorial decisions, particularly manuscript rejection, based on substantial academic, factual, or procedural grounds.

Valid grounds for appeal may include:

  1. Significant factual errors or misunderstandings affecting editorial decisions.

  2. Procedural irregularities or incorrect application of editorial criteria.

  3. Undisclosed conflicts of interest affecting manuscript evaluation.

  4. Substantial academic evidence that was overlooked during assessment.

  5. Unfair treatment or inappropriate editorial conduct.

Appeals must present clear justifications and supporting evidence. Disagreement with an academic assessment alone does not constitute sufficient grounds for reconsideration.

Complaints involving suspected research misconduct are addressed under the Allegations of Research Misconduct policy.

2. Submission of Complaints and Appeals

Complaints and appeals must be submitted in writing through the journal's Official Contact Page or the appropriate communication facilities in OJS.

Submissions should include:

  1. The complainant's or appellant's name and contact information, where applicable.

  2. The manuscript title, submission number, DOI, or article URL, if relevant.

  3. A clear explanation of the complaint or decision being challenged.

  4. Relevant supporting evidence or documentation.

  5. The clarification, reconsideration, or resolution being requested.

Editorial appeals should ordinarily be submitted by the corresponding author on behalf of the author group.

Anonymous complaints may be considered when supported by sufficiently credible and verifiable evidence.

3. Assessment and Resolution Procedures

The editorial team handles complaints and appeals through the following procedures:

  1. Receipt and Initial Assessment: The editorial office records the submission and examines its relevance, completeness, and supporting evidence.

  2. Independent Evaluation: The Editor-in-Chief or a designated independent editor assesses the matter. Individuals directly involved in the complaint or affected by a conflict of interest must not determine its outcome.

  3. Clarification and Investigation: The responsible editor may request explanations, examine editorial records, or consult independent experts when necessary.

  4. Reconsideration: Appeals presenting substantial grounds may result in an independent reassessment of the original editorial decision or additional peer review.

  5. Decision and Notification: The journal communicates the outcome and relevant explanations to the complainant or appellant through an appropriate official channel.

Complaints involving the Editor-in-Chief may be referred to an independent editorial representative or the appropriate authority within the publishing institution.

Cases will be handled without unnecessary delay. Where additional investigation is required, the journal will communicate relevant developments to the parties concerned.

4. Possible Outcomes

Depending on the findings, the journal may:

  1. Dismiss a complaint or appeal when sufficient grounds are not established.

  2. Provide clarification or correct identified administrative errors.

  3. Reconsider an editorial decision or arrange additional independent review.

  4. Reassign editorial responsibilities when a conflict of interest is identified.

  5. Implement appropriate corrective measures or refer serious concerns to the relevant institution.

An accepted appeal does not automatically result in manuscript acceptance. The original editorial decision may be upheld when the evidence does not justify reconsideration or a different outcome.

5. Confidentiality, Fairness, and Case Closure

All complaints and appeals must be handled fairly, professionally, and with appropriate confidentiality. Relevant parties must have a reasonable opportunity to provide explanations and supporting evidence.

Ar Rehla does not tolerate retaliation or unfair treatment against individuals who submit complaints or appeals in good faith.

The editorial office maintains appropriate records of complaints, assessments, decisions, and follow-up actions. Cases may be closed once an appropriate decision has been communicated.

Further reconsideration may be permitted when substantial new evidence or previously unexamined procedural concerns become available.